Catholic Group Wins Right to Display Religious Stations of the Cross on Private ‘Prayer Trail’
A Catholic group in southeastern Michigan has secured the right to place religious displays along a privately owned “prayer trail” that depicts the final moments of Jesus. This victory comes after a zoning dispute with the local government, which ultimately reached a federal appeals court.
Court Backs Catholic Group
In a unanimous 3-0 decision, the federal appeals court ruled in favor of the Catholic Healthcare International, a Missouri-based organization controlling a 40-acre wooded area in Genoa Township, Livingston County. The court issued an injunction on Monday, asserting that the township likely infringed on the rights of the Catholic group.
Zoning Dispute Background
The zoning conflict emerged when Genoa Township argued that the project was similar to constructing a church building, necessitating a special-use permit. The Catholic group objected to this requirement, leading to their proposal for a chapel and prayer trail, a move that cost them thousands of dollars in application fees but was ultimately rejected by the township.
Trail with a Purpose
Catholic Healthcare International had acquired the land from the Lansing Catholic Diocese with the intention of creating a prayer trail featuring the Stations of the Cross. These 14 stops serve as commemorations of Jesus’s suffering and death.
Legal Victory for Michiganders
In a separate legal battle, Michiganders suing the state over property damage resulting from a 2020 dam break achieved a significant legal win.
A Temporary Removal
The Stations of the Cross had been erected until 2021 when the township convinced a state judge to order their removal. In response, Catholic Healthcare filed a federal lawsuit, invoking a law designed to protect religious groups in zoning matters.
The Appeals Court’s Decision
In their unanimous decision, the appeals court affirmed that the Catholic group had a legitimate belief that their prayer trail should be treated like any other recreational area within the township. Judge Raymond Kethledge humorously likened the Stations of the Cross to “structurally akin to large birdhouses.”
The Restoration Order
Judge Kethledge, along with judges Eric Clay and Joan Larsen, declared, “Plaintiffs are entitled to a preliminary injunction allowing them to restore the Stations of the Cross, altar, and mural to their prayer trail.” The appeals court further instructed a federal judge in Flint to ensure that the religious displays are restored before September 23.
This legal victory upholds the group’s right to express their faith on their private prayer trail, a win for religious freedom in the community.