Crime Scene Expert Revisits Ohio Woman’s Murder 35 Years Later

Remembering Marjorie Coffey: Seeking Justice and Remembering a Mother’s Legacy

Alina Burroughs, a forensic expert and host of the true-crime series “Crime Scene Confidential,” is determined to ensure that the memory of a single mother of two, Marjorie “Margie” Coffey, who tragically lost her life 35 years ago, remains alive.

In January 1988, Margie Coffey’s body was discovered in an Ohio creek, frozen and lifeless. Boy Scouts, stumbling upon what they initially thought was a mannequin, found her. Her winter scarf was tightly wrapped around her neck, a grim indication of her cause of death—strangulation. The crime scene had lost much of its potential evidence, like hairs and fingerprints, over time due to the elements.

Burroughs, as the host of “Crime Scene Confidential,” delves into such cases, using modern forensic science to unravel mysteries. Through interviews with loved ones, investigators, and key players, the show sheds light on how science can solve high-profile cases across the nation.

Burroughs, known for her role as a CSI in the Caylee Anthony investigation, examines each case with the tools of modern science. An upcoming episode focusing on Margie Coffey’s case will premiere on September 6th.

Strangulation, as Burroughs highlights, reveals a deeply personal connection between the victim and the suspect. “You have to be very close to your victim in order to strangle them physically,” she explains. The act involves a willingness to watch the life leave someone’s body—a profound and disturbing connection between the perpetrator and the crime.

Margie Coffey’s life was marked by various experiences, including struggles and efforts to improve her situation. She had been arrested for soliciting prostitution in the past, but despite her challenges, she worked hard, attended church, and was determined to create a better life for her children.

As the investigation unfolds, it’s discovered that Coffey had connections with law enforcement officers. She had dated two Mansfield police officers, and one, Lieutenant Charles Oswalt, was even believed to be the father of her younger son. Despite this, Coffey’s focus was on improving her life for the sake of her children.

Despite the passage of time and the disappearance of most trace evidence, crucial fibers were found that pointed to Oswalt’s involvement. These fibers, consistent with Oswalt’s patrol vehicle, indicated a potential connection to the crime scene.

Charles Oswalt maintains his innocence, providing his perspective on the events. He acknowledges a brief encounter with Coffey years before her death but vehemently denies any involvement in her murder.

The true-crime series “Crime Scene Confidential” strives to present a comprehensive view of the case, allowing all parties to share their side of the story. The goal is to ensure justice and provide a complete picture of the events surrounding Coffey’s tragic end.

As we approach the premiere of the episode, it’s essential to remember Marjorie Coffey beyond the details of her death. She was a hardworking individual who aspired to provide a better life for her children. Her memory lives on through the efforts of professionals like Alina Burroughs, who aim to bring justice and ensure that Marjorie’s legacy is one of love and remembrance.

“Crime Scene Confidential” airs on September 6th at 9/8c on ID.

Leave a Comment